HR Compliance Audit

HR Compliance Audit

By Natasha Silveira | 8 October 2026 | 10 min read

Key takeaways

  • An HR compliance audit checks pay, contracts, records, safety and policies against the rules that apply to you.
  • Start with pay. Underpayment is the costliest finding, and intentional underpayment is now a criminal offence.
  • Test real records, not just policies. A policy on paper proves very little.
  • Rate each finding by risk, fix the high ones first and repeat the audit every year.

An HR compliance audit is the quickest way to find out what your business is getting wrong before someone else does. It shows whether you are paying people correctly, keeping the right records and following the rules on contracts, leave and safety. This checklist walks you through it in eight steps.

It is written for Australian owners, finance leads and HR managers. You don't need a legal background to start. You need access to your pay records, contracts and policies, and a few uninterrupted hours.

What is an HR compliance audit?

An HR compliance audit is a structured review of whether your employment practices meet the law. It checks pay, contracts, leave, records, workplace safety, policies and termination processes against awards, the National Employment Standards and other duties. Its purpose is to find and fix problems before a complaint, an inspector or an underpayment claim does.

An audit is different from an HR health check. A health check asks how well your HR function is working. A compliance audit asks a narrower question: are you meeting your legal obligations, and can you prove it?

It also differs from a payroll audit, which looks only at pay. A full HR compliance audit includes pay, but it goes wider. Most of the risk sits in the gaps between pay, contracts and records.

Why an HR compliance audit matters in 2026

The cost of getting it wrong has gone up, and several rules have changed recently.

Intentional underpayment is a crime. From January 2025, deliberately underpaying employees became a criminal offence under Fair Work law. Honest mistakes are not criminal, but they still have to be found, repaid and fixed. An audit is how you find them.

Super is moving to payday. From 1 July 2026, employers must pay super at the same time as wages. It must reach the employee's fund within seven business days. Systems and processes built around quarterly payments need to change.

Employers must act on harassment and safety. Since December 2022, employers have a positive duty to take reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment, sex discrimination and related conduct. Work health and safety laws also expect you to manage psychosocial hazards such as bullying and excessive workload.

Many employers have doubts. A 2025 survey by payroll compliance vendor Yellow Canary found that 93% of businesses with 50 or more employees had at least one area of concern about underpayment. The survey covered 533 Australian compliance leaders. It comes from a vendor, so treat it as a signal, not a census.

HR compliance in Australia by the numbers

7 years

how long employers must keep employee and pay records

1 day

working day to give an employee their payslip after payment

7 days

business days for super to reach the fund under Payday Super

93%

of businesses with 50+ staff had at least one underpayment concern

Sources: Fair Work Ombudsman record keeping and payslip rules; Fair Work Ombudsman, Payday Super rules from 1 July 2026; Yellow Canary 2025 State of Payroll Compliance Report (533 Australian compliance leaders, vendor survey, reported by TechRepublic, January 2025).

How to run an HR compliance audit: an eight-step checklist

Work through the steps in order. Each one builds on the last, and the pay check in step three is the one that matters most.

Step 1: Set the scope, the owner and the ground rules

Decide what the audit will cover and who is responsible. Name one person to run it and agree who will see the results. Pick a clear date range for the records you will test, such as the last 12 months.

Also decide whether the audit should be run under legal advice. If you suspect a serious problem, such as years of underpayment, ask a lawyer before you start. It is much harder to fix the approach afterwards.

Step 2: Gather your documents and data

Collect what you will need in one place before testing anything. A typical list includes:

  • A current staff list with employment type, role, classification and start date
  • Employment contracts and any individual flexibility arrangements
  • The awards and enterprise agreements that cover your people
  • Pay records, payslips, timesheets and rosters for your chosen period
  • Leave records, including accruals and balances
  • Super records and fund details
  • Your policies, handbook and onboarding documents
  • Safety records, such as incident reports, risk assessments and training logs

If gathering this takes more than a day, that is already a finding. It means your records are hard to find when someone asks for them.

Step 3: Test pay against the award or agreement

This is the heart of an HR compliance audit. For each person in your sample, check that they are on the right award and the right classification. Then recalculate a pay period by hand and compare it to what was paid.

Check these items in particular:

  • Base rates, including any recent annual increases
  • Overtime and penalty rates for evenings, weekends and public holidays
  • Allowances, such as tools, travel, first aid and meals
  • Annual leave loading and leave payouts on termination
  • Casual loading and minimum engagement periods
  • Super on the correct earnings, at the current rate
  • Payslips that show the required details and are issued on time

Sample across different roles, shifts and employment types. Include your most complicated rosters. Errors tend to hide in split shifts, public holidays and staff who changed roles mid-year.

Step 4: Review contracts and the National Employment Standards

Check that each contract matches the person's actual role, hours and award. Look for out-of-date terms, missing signatures and salary arrangements that no longer cover what the person really works.

Then check the National Employment Standards. These are the minimum entitlements that apply to all national system employees. They cover maximum weekly hours, flexible working requests, leave, public holidays, notice and redundancy pay, and information statements. Confirm that new starters receive the Fair Work Information Statement and that casual employees receive the casual employment information they are owed.

Review casual staff separately. Check whether anyone working regular, predictable hours should be offered conversion.

Step 5: Check your records and retention

Employers must keep employee and pay records for seven years. These include hours worked, pay rates, deductions, super contributions, leave accrued and taken, and employment details. Pick ten staff at random and ask for their full record. How long does it take? Is anything missing?

Check payslips too. They must be issued within one working day of payment. Make sure they are accurate and stored in a way you can retrieve them.

Step 6: Review safety, harassment and psychosocial risk

Check that you can show what you do to keep people safe. Look at incident registers, risk assessments, training records and how you handle complaints. Confirm that people know how to report bullying or harassment, and that reports are acted on and recorded.

Look at psychosocial hazards, such as high workloads, poor support and unclear roles. If you employ staff in Victoria, specific psychological health regulations apply. Ask whether your controls tackle the cause of a risk, not only the symptoms.

Step 7: Check policies, onboarding and termination

A policy is only useful if it is current and people follow it. Check the date on each one. Test whether managers know what is in them. Look at your onboarding checklist and confirm every new starter received the same documents.

Then review how you end employment. Check notice periods, final pay calculations, redundancy pay and your process for performance or conduct issues. Poor process is a common reason dismissals are challenged. Read a few recent files to see what was actually done.

Step 8: Check contractors, visas and classification

Review everyone you engage as a contractor. Misclassifying an employee as a contractor can lead to penalties for sham arrangements, backpay for leave and super, and tax problems. Ask whether the person really runs their own business, or works like an employee under your direction.

For migrant workers, confirm that you have checked visa work rights and that you track expiry dates. Work rights checks should be on file for every relevant employee.

A Real Audit vs a Box-Ticking Audit

A real audit

✓

Tests real records: pay is recalculated by hand against the award, line by line.

✓

Covers the whole picture: pay, contracts, records, safety and termination are all checked.

✓

Ends in action: every finding has an owner, a rating and a date.

A box-ticking audit

✗

Reads the policy: assumes the written policy matches what happens on the floor.

✗

Looks at pay only: misses contracts, records and safety gaps.

✗

Ends in a report: findings sit in a folder and nothing changes.

What to do with your HR compliance audit findings

An audit that finds problems has done its job. What you do next decides whether it was worth the effort.

Start by rating every finding. Use the table below to decide how fast each one needs attention. Then give each finding an owner and a date. Without those two things, nothing gets fixed.

Risk rating What it looks like What to do
High Staff underpaid, wrong award, missing super, unsafe conditions or a serious complaint left unactioned. Fix now. Calculate and repay, correct the cause and get advice.
Medium Missing records, out-of-date contracts, no manager training or unclear casual arrangements. Fix within 30 to 60 days. Assign an owner and track it.
Low Out-of-date policy wording, filing gaps or missing review dates. Fix within the next review cycle.

If you find underpayments, repay the people affected and work out how far back the problem goes. Fix the cause so it doesn't happen again. Keep a record of what you found, what you decided and what you did. Ask a lawyer or adviser how to handle it, including whether to speak with the Fair Work Ombudsman.

Don't leave a known problem alone. Intentional underpayment is a criminal matter, and knowingly ignoring a finding can look a lot like intent.

Finally, set your next audit date. Most employers should run a full HR compliance audit every year and a quick check after any major change.

Not sure what an audit would find?

A short conversation with VeiraMal will show where your pay, contracts and records are most likely to fall short, and what to fix first.

Book Your Free Discovery Call

The most common HR compliance audit findings

Every business is different, but the same problems appear again and again. Check for these first.

  • Wrong award or classification. An employee is on the wrong level, or covered by the wrong award altogether.
  • Missed allowances and penalties. Split shifts, broken shifts and public holidays are often paid at the wrong rate.
  • Salaries that don't cover the award. A flat salary falls short once overtime and penalties are counted.
  • Casual staff who work like permanent staff. Regular hours with no review of conversion rights.
  • Super paid on the wrong earnings. Or paid late, or to the wrong fund.
  • Gaps in records. Missing timesheets, leave records or signed contracts.
  • Policies nobody follows. Out-of-date handbooks and managers who haven't read them.
  • Weak termination files. No clear process, no evidence of warnings and rushed final pay.

Notice that most of these come from small, repeated habits rather than one big mistake. That is why a regular HR compliance audit works better than a one-off clean-up.

Quick scorecard: how audit-ready are you?

Tick every item that applies to your business.

Do it yourself or bring in help?

You can run the first pass yourself. If you have a small team, simple pay and good records, the checklist above is a solid start. Work through it with one person who knows your payroll well.

Bring in outside help when any of these apply: you cover several awards or agreements, you employ casuals or shift workers, you've grown quickly, you have no in-house HR, or you suspect you may have underpaid people. An independent reviewer brings fresh eyes and knows where the traps are. They can also tell you what to do about the findings.

This is general information, not legal advice. Your own obligations depend on your industry, awards, size and state.

If you want a second pair of eyes, send VeiraMal a message through the contact form or book a free discovery call. We'll tell you what to check, what to fix and what can wait.

How VeiraMal Works

1

Step one

We advise

We review your pay, contracts, records and policies, then tell you plainly what is at risk and what to fix first.

2

Step two

You approve

You see the findings, the fixes and the costs in writing and sign off only what suits your business.

3

Step three

We execute

We correct the records, update the documents and set up the checks so problems don't return.

FAQs about HR compliance audits

What is an HR compliance audit?

An HR compliance audit is a structured review of whether your employment practices meet the law. It checks pay, contracts, leave, records, workplace health and safety, policies and termination processes against awards, the National Employment Standards and other obligations. The aim is to find and fix problems before a complaint, an inspector or an underpayment claim finds them for you.

How often should I run an HR compliance audit?

At least once a year for most employers. Run an extra review after big changes, such as rapid hiring, a restructure, a new payroll system, an acquisition or a change in awards. Award pay rates also change each year, so many businesses schedule the pay check soon after the new rates start in July.

Who should run an HR compliance audit?

Someone who understands the rules and isn't marking their own homework. That might be an experienced HR or payroll lead, an independent HR consultant or your lawyer. If you expect to find serious issues, ask a lawyer whether the audit should be run under legal advice. That decision should be made before you start, not after.

What happens if an audit finds underpayments?

Fix them and repay the affected employees. Work out how far back the problem goes, correct the cause so it stops, and keep a record of what you did. Ask a lawyer or adviser about the best way to handle it, including whether to speak to the Fair Work Ombudsman. Intentional underpayment is now a criminal matter, so don't sit on a known problem.

How much does an HR compliance audit cost?

It depends on your headcount, the number of awards and agreements involved and how much of the review you do in-house. We don't quote a figure here. Ask any provider for a fixed scope in writing, including which areas are covered, how many pay records they will test and what the report will contain.

Find the Gaps Before They Find You

VeiraMal reviews your headcount, contracts, policies and termination process against the obligations that actually apply to your size. Businesses in Melbourne, Sydney and Hobart.

Book Your Free Discovery Call

Melbourne: Level 2, 480 Collins Street, VIC 3000
Sydney: Level 26, 44 Market Street, NSW 2000
Hobart: Level 6, Reserve Bank Building, 111 Macquarie Street, TAS 7000
info@veiramal.com

Thoughts from an HR expert

Stay informed with Tash Talks

Explore our monthly blogs for expert insights into industry trends and legislative updates, including HR advice Australia.

Book a free consultation

Interested to see how our HR solutions can propel your business to new heights?